Can I Replace One Garage Door Panel?

If your garage door has sustained damage from an impact, natural wear, or corrosion over time, you may wonder if replacing just one damaged panel is a viable solution. After all, it may seem unnecessary to replace an entire garage door when only a single section is affected. The answer to this question depends on several factors, including the age and condition of your current door, the extent of the damage, and whether matching replacement panels are available. Replacing one panel can be a practical and affordable fix in some situations. However, in other situations, it might only serve as a temporary solution that doesn’t address underlying issues.

Understanding when a single-panel replacement is the best option can help you make an informed decision that balances cost, safety, and aesthetics. Below, we address some of the most frequently asked questions about replacing individual garage door panels. From the potential risks and repair costs to the importance of visual consistency, we’ll help you determine whether panel replacement or a complete garage door upgrade is the best option for your home.

Garage Door Replacement FAQs

Can I replace just one garage door panel?

Yes, in many cases, you can replace a single damaged panel without replacing the entire garage door. However, this depends on the age and condition of your door. If your garage door is well-maintained and the damage is localized, replacing one panel can be a practical solution. If your door is old, shows signs of wear like peeling or flaking, or has structural issues, a full replacement may be more cost-effective and visually appealing.

What are the risks of replacing only one panel?

There are a few risks to consider before replacing a single panel:

• Internal Damage: Sometimes the issue goes beyond the visible panel. Hidden damage to springs, rails, or hinges can affect your garage door’s stability and performance.

• Functionality: A new panel may alter the door’s balance or alignment, especially if the tracks or other panels are not perfectly straight.

• Aesthetics: Even if the panel fits correctly, it may not match the existing door color or style, affecting curb appeal.

How much does it cost to replace a garage door panel?

The cost of a single garage door panel replacement typically ranges from $200 to $700, depending on the door model and material. Replacing one panel can be cheaper than replacing the whole door. However, if your door is older and multiple panels are damaged, a full door replacement might be more economical in the long run.

Can I replace a garage door panel myself?

It’s technically possible but not recommended. Garage doors are heavy and require precise alignment, special tools, and expertise to ensure safety. Attempting to replace a panel yourself can lead to personal injury or system damage.

How can I match a replacement garage door panel to my existing door?

To achieve the best match:

• Identify the Manufacturer: Tell your technician who made your garage door so they can check for matching parts.

• Repaint for Consistency: If an exact match isn’t available, repainting the entire door or new panel can help blend the finish.

Is replacing one garage door panel worth it?

If your garage door is fairly new and the damage is minimal, replacing a single panel can be cost-effective. But for aging doors or those with internal wear, a full replacement may save money over time and improve curb appeal.

Contact Midwest Garage Door Company Today

At Midwest Garage Door Company, our skilled professionals provide inspection and maintenance services to address the impacts of temperature, humidity, and seasonal wear. Whether it’s realigning components or replacing panels, we’re here to help repair your garage door.

We proudly serve central and southern Illinois, including Sangamon, Morgan, Christian, Logan, Macoupin, and Montgomery counties. To learn more or schedule a consultation, contact our team today, and be sure to visit our FAQs page for helpful safety information.